The Old Mill Restaurant

164 Old Mill Ave, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863, USA

About The Old Mill Restaurant

4.7 / 5

from reviews

    June 19, 2024

    Very cool place to eat! Very family friendly, and prices are affordable. We loved everything we ordered. We each selected a main entree, and the sides are all served family style. Our side were green beans, mashed potatoes, and corn meal nuggets. The whole pecan pie was shared the next day, and was really good! I highly recommend this place when visiting this area!

    Mark Johnson
    May 26, 2024

    First you get a small bowl of world class corn chowder that was out of this world good. Service was perfect, never waited on anything from service staff. You get corn fritters and biscuit/roll with a soft butter that hints of some maple. Then i had the lunch portion of turkey with dressing, green beans and mashed potatoes. My wife had meatloaf with the same sides. The lunch portions were huge. 8-10 thick slices of turkey over a large bed of dressing smothered in gravy. I ate until full and there were at least half my portions untouched. The menu was open with many offerings. I would strongly suggest this place and the prices were low for the quality and quantity of my servings. Only thing remotely negative about this place is the wait time. At lunch we waited about 35 min. So just plan accordingly. It is first come first served, no reservations.

    Osvaldo Silvera
    June 18, 2024

    It's a great place and worth the wait! Arrived at about 720p and got on the waiting list, they said an hour and about 50 minutes later we were sat. I love that all the other shops in the immediate area are connected to the intercom system. So that you can walk around and go shopping and still hear your name being called when it's your time to head back to the hostess stand. Autumn was our server and she was just super nice, very knowledgable and quick to help. There were 5 of us. All of the food was pretty great, and plentiful. Of all the food only the ribs were a bit chewy and undercooked, they were very receptive and offered to replace them with anything else on the menu but we decided not to. They removed it from the bill without us asking. Top notch customer service! Great value and we will be back!!..pS.. the Pecan pie is the best I've ever had!

    R T
    May 02, 2024

    Remains the best after first visit 20 years ago. Had about a 30 minute wait on a Saturday, but well worth it. Service was excellent and the server never missed a beat. Food was excellent. Definitely quality ingredients and the quantity of the food was good compared to most restaurants today that look for ways to cheat customers. The only regret... I didn't return for a second meal during my trip.

    Anthony P
    April 28, 2024

    This place is legendary! The food, service and hospitality is incredible. For $25 you basically get served a feast. The biscuits with corn fritters and butter to start are ridiculous. Corn chowder served next is excellent. You then get a small salad with a choice of dressing. Then the main course. I had the fried catfish which was outrageous and my wife had the fried chicken and it was also outstanding. The serve it with big bowls of excellent mashed potatoes and wonderful stewed green beans cooked with ham. So good. You also get a dessert. I had the best pecan pie ever! They brought the kids fresh vanilla ice cream on the house. What an amazing restaurant. I can't say it enough.

    The Old Mill Restaurant

    Our Address

    164 Old Mill Ave, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863, USA

    Request A Listing

    We Will Be In Touch If You Have Questions and/or to Get You Listed.