Old Mill Creamery

171 Old Mill Ave #3515, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863, USA

About Old Mill Creamery

4.4 / 5

from reviews

    Lydia Rigel
    September 01, 2022

    Delicious ice cream! It’s very creamy and flavorful. The oat mill cookie ice cream was so unique and definitely worth trying! We couldn’t believe how reasonable the prices are. Highly recommend!

    April 24, 2022

    The atmosphere of this store is similar to that of a mom-and-pop shop. The banana pudding ice cream was just like the eponymous flavor name. 5 stars all the way.

    Jon and Amanda Lewis
    August 25, 2021

    Brown Butter Black Walnut was some of the best ice cream I have had in a long time. Cookies and Cream and Cookie dough were excellent as well. Staff was friendly. Prices were affordable. I would highly recommend this place!

    Gail Reese
    June 28, 2022

    Old Mill Creamery is my favorite stop when we come to town. The from-scratch ice cream is literally the best I’ve ever had! Oatmill Cream Pie is their best, but you can’t go wrong with any of their unique flavors! The Banana Pudding is fantastic and the Peanut Butter tastes like homemade peanut butter fudge. The staff is always friendly and the portions are well worth the price, which I think are very reasonable. Surrounded by lots of fun shops to visit while you enjoy your cone, Old Mill Creamery is a must visit!

    Tina Rimner
    October 01, 2022

    We have been going to the Creamery for over 31 years. This is the 1st place we go when our family gets settled into our vacation stay. I always order a banana split. Not this year, the past 2 years have been very disappointing. The service is not the same and the banana split is horrible. I wished I could post the pictures of the banana split from the past and the present very disappointing. They last2 visits they have not even had Bananas. We will be finding another ice cream place to go from now own

    Old Mill Creamery

    Our Address

    171 Old Mill Ave #3515, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863, USA

    Request A Listing

    We Will Be In Touch If You Have Questions and/or to Get You Listed.